This site is hosted by
MitchellMedia.com

  Reflections on Temptation Island 1  
     
 

They should have called this show "the big tease." Don't get be wrong, I liked the show. However, the show was fundamentally flawed. The flaw was that anything would happen, other than a bit of teasing.

I don't know about other people, but I tuned into this show for the same reason that I occasionally tune in MTV's "Spring Break," namely, to see people making a fool of themselves on national TV. And, it almost happened, and probably would have happened, if the show had not been fundamentally flawed from the beginning.

First, what person is their right mind would cheat on their significant other on national TV. Well, this is not such a huge flaw. From watching other reality TV shows, I have observed that, after spending several days on camera, most people tend to forget about the cameras and just behave as if there are none. So, Kaya, who was sucking face with Megan after spending one day with her and who was sucking face with Alison, one day later, would have cheated, given enough time. I think that the same goes for Shannon, who seemed to be swept off her feet by Tom. But, there is no way that this going to happen when they are only away from their significant other for 10 days.

Kaya said "after five days, I was just beginning to be comfortable with the idea that I could let go and have fun with another woman." But, then five days later, the show was over. If Kaya had been away from Valerie for five more days, I think that he would have succumbed to temptation. As it was, he was happy on the final day because he resisted and he did not make a fool of himself on national TV. But, who couldn't have passed such a lame test? If Kaya can pass this lame test, then anyone can.

Again, I tuned into this show to see people totally embarrass themselves. And, there were some interesting moments. But, there just was NOT ENOUGH TIME. This is the really big flaw in the show. After eight or nine days apart from their significan others, the action is just beginning to heat up. Then, before anyone is really tempted, on day 10, the show is over.

What kind of idiots did the producers think that they were inviting on the show? Well, I must commend the casting because they did indeed choose eager beavers, i.e., some of the tempers were more than ready to jump in the sack. Vanessa told Billy that he had the green light after their first date. Megan was playing tonsil hockey with Kaya on their first date. Alison seemed to like Kaya, and she is self professed to "have a wild side." But, it was the couples who were resisting the temptation.

The couples resisted because they did not want to have a sleazy one-night stand and then suffer the consequences when their significant other confronted them. However, if there was more time, it would not have been a one-night stand; rather, it would have been a romantic journey.

Mandy said on the last episode that it was only on the last day that she felt the transition between "having fun" and "taking a journey." Shannon was overwhelmed by Tom, and so on their last night together, they stayed up all night and watched the sunrise, together. Billy struggled with whether or not "to hook up with" Vanessa for several days. In fact, Billy probably struggled the most, since after going out with Vanessa on his third date, Billy decided to focus his attention on her. However, even though these four (Mandy, Shannon, Billy and Kaya) felt like they made a "real connection" with these singles, yet none of them were willing to have a one-night stand. And who would be?

So, the short of the matter is this. If there had been about three more episodes and about five or six more days on the island, the outcome would have been much different. Here is what I think would have happened:
1. Kaya would have succumbed to temptation and would have been squirming at the final bonfire. Rather than saying "I am happy that I did this" and "I have no regrets," we would have seen a completely different Kaya--for example, "I cannot believe I did this on national TV."
2. Mandy would have been doing the horizontal mambo with Jon, and although they would have tried to hide it from the cameras at first, after a few days, she would have been telling the cameras what a great lover he is.
3. Shannon would have convinced herself that she and Tom are eternal soul mates, and they would have been ordering room service for days.
4. Billy would have scratched his bald head and said, "Damn it, I have not gotten laid in two weeks, Mandy will understand; let's jump in the sack." In other words, Billy would have justified a roll in the hay.

Of course Valerie and Andy would have had a miserable time, but who cares about Valerie and Andy, anyway? LOL

This whole show was ill conceived from the beginning. The couples were only apart from their significant others for 10 days, during which time, each had four dates (and for most, with four different people). Then, they were invited to focus on one person and to spend the night with that person. That's not TEMPTATION!

Unless the singles are given more time with those who are supposed to be tempted (e.g., 15 days rather than 10 days), I will not be tuning into the next show. It is just "Teaser Island." I would like to see the couples have a romanic journey. But, as it stands, the couples are offered a cheap one-night stand, and none are even tempted.

 
 
RealityTVPlanet
 
  So, what do you think?